Turkey...

Its not evil.  It's within period.  People actually ate it.  There are days when I think I am the only person who thinks it would be cool to play with this bird in an SCA setting.  After all, we don't have a lot of large birds available to us.  Last time I checked, they frowned upon us using swans and peacock.

Edit: And... its not as if I would ever serve potato or tomato... those killed people and were outright banned in most courts.